Aperture 1.5: External editor not bringing image back into Aperture?

I am running Aperture 1.5 and have Noise Ninja installed as my external editor. I can successfully send an image from my Aperture library to NN and edit it there, but when I save the image, it is not brought back into Aperture. Further, if I try to send another image from Aperture to NN while NN is open, a new TIFF version is created in Aperture, but nothing opens up in NN.
I've been using Aperture and NN for about a year, and it has always acted like this, so I've basically given up on trying to use the External Editing feature in Aperture, but after some research it seemed like this shouldn't be as difficult as it has been for me.
Has anyone else had a problem like this and been able to resolve it? And does it matter that my files are referenced, and not stored in the Aperture library?
Thanks all


Did you ever find a solution? I'm having the same problem with Photoshop files not saving back into Aperture. I haven't been able to figure it out.

Problem Using Aperture as an External Editor

I'm having a problem using Aperture as an external editor for iPhoto. I've set preferences to "Edit in Aperture" and selected the Aperture application. When I click edit a photo in iPhoto, Aperture fires up as expected, but it does not load my p

HT1688 during a software update, i lost all my apps. restore did not bring them back, how do i get my apps back?

during a software update, i lost all my apps. restore did not bring them back, how do i get my apps back?Your apps will only be where you put them.  if you failed to put them on your computer beore updating, then they would certainly be gone. You can

Aperture - Edit with External Editor - Photoshop

Hi, I recently made my first attempt via Aperture to "Edit with External Editor" and in my case I have the preferences set to export to Photoshop CS4 Extended. The External Editor File Format (in preferences) selected is TIFF and as advised by A

If Adobe has disabled the ability to use Lightroom 5.7 to view the images in the external harddrive, how does one view the images in the file on the external drive without bringing them back to the Lightroom Library?

Jpeg images dragged over from Photoshop are veiwable as thumbnails on the external harddrive.  However images brought over as RAW of DNG are not viewable.  Is there anyway to view these type images on the external harddrive?  It would be nice to have

"open in external editor" not working

I use "open in external editor" a lot to edit pictures in Photoshop, but it has stopped working. Now it launches Photoshop, but doesn't open/load the relevant image. What has changed since I had this working? I had a couple of kernel panics, and

Photoshop Elements 9 Editor not showing images in Project Bin

Yesterday I went though my PE9 Organiser and rearrange some of my files and made sure that it was more user friendly. Today I went in to try and do some edits and not all of the folders are showing up in PE9 Project Bin. I can view some images, but n

CMD+Tab between apps does not bring fullscreen window into focus.

I just upgraded to Mountain Lion from Snow Leopard and now I can't tab between fullscreen apps and regular screened apps. Let me clarify then that my Cmd-Tab function itself still works (the toolbar for whatever application I switch to appears at the

Aperture 3.0.3 will not sync images with iPad via iTunes correctly

I've read the forums looking for a solution to why my Aperture 3 library will not sync with my iPad when it is connected in iTunes. I have tried creating another Aperture library (which I then fill with a few images) and iTunes is able to see and imp

New hard drive, can't get photos to load from "iTunes sync" back into aperture or iPhoto

My hard drive crashed while in for service. I had over 10,000 photos in aperture and they were not able to recover any of them. When I connected my iPhone 5 to iTunes, I see at the bar on the bottom that shows storage that there are 10,000+ photos bu

Images won't open in Adobe external editor

I can't get my images to open up in Photoshop eventhough it is set up as my external editor. When I select a picture to open with via the chosen external editor, a second version of my original is made within Aperture(with the external editor badge o

Saving to Aperture after using Photoshop as an External Editor

I'd be grateful for guidance please. I use Aperture but sometimes use the external editor (Photoshop in my case). When I have finished editing in Photoshop what is the best way to get the finished photograph back into Aperture? Do I have to do anothe

Why use an external editor?

I have done a search on this basic question, but everyone is at least one step ahead of me. I found lots of questions about using external editors, but none on why to use one if the first place. It's self-evident that the basic answer is to extend Ap

Photoshop Elements 11 External Editor

I have selected Photoshop Elements 11 as my external editor within Aperture 3.  When I select PSE 11, Aperture opens PSE but does not export the picture to PSE.  Is there a solution to this issues?Have you selected the PS Elements Editor and not anot

Where does my saved file go after using photoshop as external editor

Okay, I understand that when I have a 30MB picture file and edit with photoshop afterwards, I click on Save and back into aperture i'm left with a 175MB picture (bigger or smaller sometimes), but my question is this: Since i'm working with all refere

If I use Lightroom as an external editor within iPhoto...

how do I get the image back into iPhoto? There is no "save" command.Scott: If you have Photoshop or Photoshop Element I would recommend you use one of those as your editor of choice within iPhoto. That way you can just edit and save (as long as

Dragging Images Out Of Aperture 3 Halves Resolution?

When I drag my images out of Aperture 3 into Photoshop or onto my desktop, it halves the resolution and drops the dpi to 72. If I put the image back in Aperture and repeat the process, the resolution halves again. Any idea as to why?, but when you're

Problems importing Aperture 2 archived projects into Aperture 3

Any suggestions please I want to import some archived projects from aperture 2 back into Aperture 3 from an external dive the projects are in folders named xxxx.approject. Aperture 3 sees the folders but the images are contained in separate folders w

Referencing a single Iphoto Event into Aperture

Hi Everyone, I recently imported my entire iPhoto library into Aperture making sure that 'store files' was set to 'In their current location' so that Aperture would reference from iPhoto. This worked fine. My problem... I recently imported a new batc

Am I correct that Photos does not support external editors? i.e., in Aperture, I click Photos Edit with.... and can open in Photoshop or various plug-ins. Changes are then automatically saved back to Aperture. Nonexistent in Photos?

Am I correct that Photos does not support external editors? i.e., in Aperture, I click Photos > Edit with.... and can open in Photoshop or various plug-ins. Changes are then automatically saved back to Aperture. Nonexistent in Photos?Thanks Larry. Th